Medium speed enginesintroduction

New designs and upgraded versions of established models have maintained the dominance of medium speed four-stroke diesel engines in the propulsion of smaller ships as well as larger specialist tonnage such as cruise vessels, car/passenger ferries and ro-ro freight carriers. The larger bore designs can also target the mainstream cargo ship propulsion market formed by bulk carriers, containerships and tankers, competing against low speed two-stroke machinery. The growth of the fast ferry sector has benefited those medium speed enginebuilders (notably Caterpillar and Ruston) who can offer designs with sufficiently high power/weight and volume ratios, an ability to function reliably at full load for sustained periods, and attractive through-life operating costs. Medium speed engines further enjoy supremacy in the deepsea genset drive sector, challenged only in lower power installations by high speed four-stroke engines.

Significant strides have been made in improving the reliability and durability of medium speed engines in the past decade, both at the design stage and through the in-service support of advanced monitoring and diagnostic systems. Former weak points in earlier generations of medium speed engines have been eradicated in new models which have benefited from finite element method calculations in designing heavily loaded components. Designers now argue the merits of new generations of longer stroke medium speed engines with higher specific outputs allowing a smaller number of cylinders to satisfy a given power demand and foster compactness, reliability, reduced maintenance and easier servicing. Progress in fuel and lubricating oil economy is also cited, along with enhanced pier-to-pier heavy fuel burning capability and better performance flexibility throughout the load range.

Completely bore-cooled cylinder units and combustion spaces formed by liner, head and piston combine good strength and stiffness with good temperature control which are important factors in burning low quality fuel oils. Low noise and vibration levels achieved by modern medium speed engines can be reduced further by resilient mounting systems, a technology which has advanced considerably in recent years.

IMO limits on nitrogen oxides emissions in the exhaust gas can generally be met comfortably by medium speed engines using primary measures to influence the combustion process (in some cases, it is claimed, without compromising specific fuel consumption). Wartsila's low NOx combustion technology, for example, embraces high fuel injection pressures (up to 2000 bar) to reduce the duration of injection; a high compression ratio (16:1); a maximum cylinder pressure of up to 210 bar; and a stroke/bore ratio greater than 1.2:1. Concern over smoke emissions, particularly by cruise ship operators in sensitive environmental areas, has called for special measures from engine designers targeting that market, notably electronically-controlled common rail fuel injection and fuel-water emulsification.

Ease of inspection and overhaul—an important consideration in an era of low manning levels and faster turnarounds in port—was addressed in the latest designs by a reduced overall number of components (in some cases, 40 per cent fewer than in the preceding engine generation) achieved by integrated and modular assemblies using multi-functional components. Simplified (often plug-in or clamped) connecting and quick-acting sealing arrangements also smooth maintenance procedures. Channels for lubricating oil, cooling water, fuel and air may be incorporated in the engine block or other component castings, leaving minimal external piping in evidence. Compact and more accessible installations are achieved by integrating ancillary support equipment (such as pumps, filters, coolers and thermostats) on the engine. Lower production costs are also sought from design refinements and the wider exploitation of flexible manufacturing systems to produce components.

The cylinder unit concept is a feature of the latest four-stroke designs, allowing the head, piston, liner and connecting rod to be removed together as a complete assembly for repair, overhaul or replacement by a renovated unit onboard or ashore. This modular approach was adopted by MAN B&W for its L16/24, L21/31and L27/38 designs, by MTU for its Series 8000 engine, by Rolls-Royce for its Bergen C-series, and by Hyundai for its H21/32 design: all detailed in subsequent chapters.

Compactness and reduced weight remain the key attractions of the medium speed engine, offering ship designers the opportunity to increase the cargo capacity and lower the cost of a given newbuilding project, and the ability to achieve via reduction gearing the most efficient propeller speed. Medium speed enginebuilders can offer solutions ranging from single-engine plants for small cargo vessels to multi-engine/twin-screw installations for the most powerful passenger ships, based on mechanical (geared) or electrical transmissions (see Chapter 6). Multi-engine configurations promote plant availability and operational flexibility, allowing the number of prime movers engaged at any time to match the service schedule. The convenient direct drive of alternators and other engineroom auxiliary plant (hydraulic power packs, for example) is also facilitated via power takeoff gearing.

Among the design innovations in recent years must be noted Sulzer's use of hydraulic actuation of the gas exchange valves for its ZA50S engine, the first time that this concept (standard on low speed two-stroke engines for many years) had been applied to medium speed four-stroke engines (Figure 16.5). In conjunction with pneumatically

Medium Speed Engine

Figure 16.1 The Japanese ADD 30V engine is distinguished by a single-valve gas exchange system comprising a main valve located at the centre of the cylinder and a control valve placed co-axially against the main valve. The control valve switches the air intake and exhaust channels in the cylinder cover. Both valves are driven hydraulically. Side-mounted fuel injectors are arranged around the cylinder periphery

Figure 16.1 The Japanese ADD 30V engine is distinguished by a single-valve gas exchange system comprising a main valve located at the centre of the cylinder and a control valve placed co-axially against the main valve. The control valve switches the air intake and exhaust channels in the cylinder cover. Both valves are driven hydraulically. Side-mounted fuel injectors are arranged around the cylinder periphery

Sulzer Exhaust LayoutHidraulic Cylinder Exploted

Figure 16.1 (Continued)

controlled load-dependent timing to secure variable inlet closing, hydraulic actuation on the ZA50S engine allows flexibility in valve timing, fostering lower exhaust gas emissions and improved fuel economy.

Variable inlet closing, combined with optimized turbocharging, contributes to a very flat fuel consumption characteristic across the load range of the engine as well as a considerable reduction in smoke levels in part-load operation. The ZA50S engine, like the smaller bore

ZA40S design it was derived from, features Sulzer's rotating piston which was also exploited in GMT's upgraded 550 mm bore medium speed engine.

Wartsila's 46 engine exploited a number of innovations in medium speed technology, originally including a twin fuel injection system (featuring pilot and main injection valves), thick-pad bearings (large bearings with thick oil films) and pressure-lubricated piston skirts. The twin injection system was later superseded as advances in fuel injection technology allowed a single-valve system to be applied.

The operating flexibility of MAN B&W's L32/40 design benefits from the provision of separate camshafts, arranged on either side of the engine, for the fuel injection and valve actuating gear. One camshaft is dedicated to drive the fuel injection pumps and to operate the starting air pilot valves; the other serves the inlet and exhaust valves. Such an arrangement allows fuel injection and air charge renewal to be controlled independently, and thus engine operation to be more conveniently optimized for either high fuel economy or low exhaust emissions mode. Injection timing can be adjusted by turning the camshaft relative to the camshaft driving gear (an optional facility (Figure 16.2)). The valve-actuating camshaft can be provided with different cams for full-load and part-load operations, allowing valve timing to be tailored to the conditions. A valve camshaft-shifting facility is optional, the standard engine version featuring just one cam contour (Figure 16.3).

A carbon cutting ring is now a common feature of medium speed engines specified to eliminate the phenomenon of cylinder bore polishing caused by carbon deposits and hence significantly reduce liner wear. It also fosters a cleaner piston ring area, low and very stable lubricating oil consumption, and reduced blow-by.

Also termed an anti-polishing or fire ring, a carbon cutting ring comprises a sleeve insert which sits between the top piston ring turning point and the top of the cylinder liner. It has a slightly smaller diameter than the bore of the liner, this reduction being accommodated by a reduced diameter for the top land of the piston. The main effect of the ring is to prevent the build-up of carbon around the edges of the piston crown which causes liner polishing and wear, with an associated rise in lubricating oil consumption. A secondary function is a sudden compressive effect on the ring belt as the piston and carbon cutting ring momentarily interface. Lubricating oil is consequently forced away from the combustion area, again helping to reduce consumption: so effectively, in fact, that Bergen Diesel found it necessary to redesign the ring pack to allow a desirable amount of oil consumption. Lubricating oil consumption, the Norwegian engine designer reports,

Carbon Cutting Ring Cylinder Liner

Or O

Cuttings Reinjection System

is cut by more than half and insoluble deposits in the oil reduced dramatically, significantly extending oil filter life. Carbon cutting rings can be retrofitted to deliver their benefits to engines in service. Removal prior to piston withdrawal is simply effected with a special tool.

Designers now also favour a 'hot box' arrangement for the fuel injection system to secure cleaner engine lines and improve the working environment in the machinery room thanks to reduced temperatures; additionally, any fuel leakage from the injection system components is retained within the box.

The major medium speed enginebuilders have long offered 500 mm-bore-plus designs in their portfolios. MAN B&W still fields the L58/64 series and SEMT-Pielstick its 570 mm bore PC4.2 and PC40L series, but MaK's 580 mm bore M601 and the Sulzer ZA50S engines have been phased out, as was Stork-Wartsila's TM620 engine in the mid-1990s.

In the 1970s MAN and Sulzer jointly developed a V-cylinder 650 mm bore/stroke design (developing 1325 kW/cylinder at 400 rev/min) that did not proceed beyond prototype testing.

Wartsila's 64 series, launched in 1996, took the medium speed engine into a higher power and efficiency territory, the 640 mm bore/ 900 mm stroke design now offering an output of 2010 kW/cylinder at 333 rev/min. A V12-cylinder model delivers 23 280 kW at 400 rev/ min. The range can therefore meet the propulsive power demands of virtually all merchant ship tonnage types with either single- or multi-engine installations. The key introductory parameters were: 10 m/s mean piston speed; 25 bar mean effective pressure; and 190 bar maximum cylinder pressure. The Finnish designers claimed the 64 series to be the first medium speed engine to exceed the 50 per cent thermal efficiency barrier, and suggested that overall plant efficiencies of 57-58 per cent are possible from a combi-cycle exploiting waste heat to generate steam for a turbo-alternator.

At the other end of the medium speed engine power spectrum, the early 1990s saw the introduction of a number of 200 mm bore long stroke designs from leading builders, such as Daihatsu, MaK and Wartsila Diesel, contesting a sector already targeted by Sulzer's S20 model. These heavy fuel-burning engines (typically with a 1.5:1 stroke/bore ratio) were evolved for small-ship propulsion and genset drive duties, the development goals addressing overall operating economy, reliability, component durability, simplicity of maintenance and reduced production costs. Low and short overall configurations gave more freedom to naval architects in planning machinery room layouts and eased installation procedures (Figure 16.4).

The circa-320 mm bore sector is fiercely contested by designers

Figure 16.4 MaK's M20 engine, representing a new breed of 200 mm bore designs

serving a high volume market created by propulsion and genset drive demands. A number of new designs—including Caterpillar/MaK's M32 and MAN B&W Diesel's L32/40 —emerged to challenge upgraded established models such as the Wartsila 32.

A Japanese challenger in a medium speed arena traditionally dominated by European designer/licensors arrived in the mid-1990s after several years' R&D by the Tokyo-based Advanced Diesel Engine Development Company. The joint venture embraced Hitachi Zosen, Kawasaki Heavy Industries and Mitsui Engineering and Shipbuilding. The 300 mm bore/480 mm stroke ADD30V design, in a V50-degree configuration, developed up to 735 kW/cylinder at 750 rev/min, significantly more powerful than contemporary medium speed engines of equivalent bore size. A mean effective pressure of around 25 bar and a mean piston speed of 11.5 m/s were exploited in tests with a six-cylinder prototype, although an mep approaching 35 bar and a mean piston speed of 12 m/s are reportedly possible. In addition to a high specific output, the developers sought a design which was also over 30 per cent lighter in weight, 10-15 per cent more fuel economical and with a better part-load performance than established engines. Underwriting these advances in mep and mean piston speed ratings are an anti-wear ceramic coating for the sliding surfaces of the cylinder liners and piston rings, applied by a plasma coating method. A porous ceramic heat shield was also developed for the combustion chamber to reduce heat transfer to the base metal of the piston crown.

A key feature is the single-valve air intake and exhaust gas exchange (Figure 16.1), contrasting with the four-valve (two inlet and two exhaust) heads of other medium speed engines. The greatly enlarged overall dynamic valve area and the reduction in pressure losses during the gas exchange period promote a higher thermal efficiency. The system is based on a heat-resistant alloy main poppet valve located over the centre of the cylinder and a control valve placed co-axially against this main valve. The control valve switches the air intake and exhaust channels in the cylinder cover. Both main and control valves are driven hydraulically.

Fuel injection is executed from the side through multiple injectors arranged around the cylinder periphery instead of a conventional top-mounted central injection system. Combustion characteristics were optimized by raising the fuel injection pressure to around 2000 bar, thus enhancing the fuel-air mixture formation and fostering low NOx emissions without sacrificing fuel economy. A computer-based mechatronics system automatically controls the timing of fuel injection and valve opening/closing to match the operating conditions. The first 6ADD30V production marine engines, built by Mitsui, were specified

Sulzer L58
Figure 16.5 The first example of the Sulzer ZA50S engine, a nine-cylinder model, on test. The design (no longer produced) was distinguished by hydraulic actuation of the gas exchange valves

as the prime movers for the diesel-electric propulsion plant of a large Japanese survey vessel.

Offshore industry market opportunities—and the potential of mainstream shipping interest—have encouraged a number of medium speed enginebuilders to develop dual-fuel and gas-diesel designs offering true multi-fuel capabilities with high efficiency and reliability, and low carbon dioxide emissions. The engines can run on gas (with a small percentage of liquid pilot fuel) or entirely on liquid fuel (marine diesel oil, heavy fuel or even crude oil). Switching from one fuel to another is possible without interrupting power generation. (See Chapter 2.)

The high cost of R&D to maintain a competitive programme and continuing investment in production resources and global support services have stimulated a number of joint ventures and takeovers in the four-stroke engine sector in recent years. Most notable have been Wartsila's acquisition of the former New Sulzer Diesel and Caterpillar's takeover of MaK. Earlier, Wartsila had acquired another leading medium speed enginebuilder, the Netherlands-based Stork-Werkspoor Diesel. This trend towards an industry comprising a small number of major multi-national players contesting the world market has continued with the absorption of the British companies Mirrlees Blackstone, Paxman and Ruston (formerly part of Alstom Engines) into the MAN B&W Diesel group. Rolls-Royce inherited the Bergen Diesel interests in Norway through the takeover of Vickers-Ulstein, adding to its Allen programme.

Considerable potential remains for further developing the power ratings of medium speed engines, whose cylinder technology has benefited in recent years from an anti-polishing ring at the top of the liner, water distribution rings, chrome-ceramic piston rings, pressurized skirt lubrication and nodular cast iron/low friction skirt designs.

The pressure-lubricated skirt elevated the scuffing limit originally obtaining by more than 50 bar, reduced piston slap force by 75 per cent and doubled the lifetime of piston rings and grooves. Furthermore, it facilitated a reduction in lube oil consumption and, along with the simultaneous introduction of the nodular cast iron skirt, practically eliminated the risk of piston seizure. The anti-polishing ring dramatically improved cylinder liner lifetime beyond 100 000 hours, and lube oil consumption became controllable and stable over time, most engines today running at rates between 0.1 and 0.5 g/kWh. A further reduction in piston ring and groove wear was also achieved, and the time-between-overhauls extended to 18 000-20 000 hours. The ring itself is a wear part but is turnable in four positions in a four-stroke engine, fostering a lengthy lifetime for the component.

Such elements underwrite a capability to support a maximum cylinder pressure of 250 bar, of which 210-230 bar is already exploited in some engines today. Leading designers such as Wartsila suggest it may be possible to work up towards 300 bar with the same basic technology for the cylinder unit, although some areas need to be developed: bearing technology, for example, where there is potential in both geometry and materials. A steel piston skirt may become the most cost effective, and cooling of the piston top will probably change from direct oil cooling to indirect. The higher maximum cylinder pressure can be exploited for increasing the maximum effective pressure or improving the thermal efficiency of the process. Continuing to mould the development of the medium speed engine will be: NOx emissions; CO2 emissions; fuel flexibility; mean time-between-failures; and reduced maintenance.

Do It Yourself Car Diagnosis

Do It Yourself Car Diagnosis

Don't pay hundreds of dollars to find out what is wrong with your car. This book is dedicated to helping the do it yourself home and independent technician understand and use OBD-II technology to diagnose and repair their own vehicles.

Get My Free Ebook

Post a comment